thedrifter
01-10-07, 11:11 AM
January 10, 2007
Think tank: Anbar RCTs would help secure Baghdad
By Kimberly Johnson
kjohnson@militarytimes.com
Sending two additional Marine regimental combat teams into Iraq’s Anbar province to secure inroads into Baghdad would help U.S. military commanders hold the capital during surge operations, an American Enterprise Institute report said.
The extra Marines could also be necessary in Baghdad, the conservative think tank said.
AEI’s proposed surge plans are significant because its scholars and their Iraq war stance are considered closely aligned with that of the Bush administration.
Adding two RCTs to Anbar to the two existing RCTs and one Army Brigade Combat Team would essentially double the Marine presence in the Sunni-dominated province in Western Iraq, bringing the total troops numbers in the region to around 18,000.
“The Army and Marine presence in Anbar is inadequate to maintain even the most basic security in that province,” the report said. Pulling troops from Anbar or Diyala — the province considered an al-Qaida base north of Baghdad — to reinforce the capital “would almost surely lead to the further collapse of those regions,” it added.
AEI’s assessment of the state of affairs in Anbar counters statements made recently by the Corps’ top commander following his visit to Marine bases in Iraq during the holidays.
“I don’t think that a surge in a strict sense of putting a number of additional battalions in here is what they seem to need right now,” Commandant Gen. James Conway said Dec. 26 while in Fallujah. “If you look for the identifiable military objectives in Al Anbar that would justify a surge there, I don’t know if [commander of Multi-National Force-West Maj. Gen. Richard Zilmer] could give one at this point,” he said.
In addition to sending in two RCTs, AEI proposed in its Jan. 5 report sending in five more BCTs, for a total of about 30,000 additional troops.
Central to AEI’s plan is bringing sectarian violence down to a level that would allow political and economic reforms to take root alongside the training of Iraqi security forces.
Ellie
Think tank: Anbar RCTs would help secure Baghdad
By Kimberly Johnson
kjohnson@militarytimes.com
Sending two additional Marine regimental combat teams into Iraq’s Anbar province to secure inroads into Baghdad would help U.S. military commanders hold the capital during surge operations, an American Enterprise Institute report said.
The extra Marines could also be necessary in Baghdad, the conservative think tank said.
AEI’s proposed surge plans are significant because its scholars and their Iraq war stance are considered closely aligned with that of the Bush administration.
Adding two RCTs to Anbar to the two existing RCTs and one Army Brigade Combat Team would essentially double the Marine presence in the Sunni-dominated province in Western Iraq, bringing the total troops numbers in the region to around 18,000.
“The Army and Marine presence in Anbar is inadequate to maintain even the most basic security in that province,” the report said. Pulling troops from Anbar or Diyala — the province considered an al-Qaida base north of Baghdad — to reinforce the capital “would almost surely lead to the further collapse of those regions,” it added.
AEI’s assessment of the state of affairs in Anbar counters statements made recently by the Corps’ top commander following his visit to Marine bases in Iraq during the holidays.
“I don’t think that a surge in a strict sense of putting a number of additional battalions in here is what they seem to need right now,” Commandant Gen. James Conway said Dec. 26 while in Fallujah. “If you look for the identifiable military objectives in Al Anbar that would justify a surge there, I don’t know if [commander of Multi-National Force-West Maj. Gen. Richard Zilmer] could give one at this point,” he said.
In addition to sending in two RCTs, AEI proposed in its Jan. 5 report sending in five more BCTs, for a total of about 30,000 additional troops.
Central to AEI’s plan is bringing sectarian violence down to a level that would allow political and economic reforms to take root alongside the training of Iraqi security forces.
Ellie