Marines battle moral dilemma

Updated 6:58 AM on Sunday, July 15, 2007

Marines battle moral dilemma

Initiative boosts training values, battlefield ethics

By THOMAS WATKINS
Associated Press


SAN DIEGO - Perched atop a stack of foot lockers in a spotless barracks, drill instructor Gunnery Sgt. Celestino Casias asks 45 shaved-headed recruits what it takes to be a Marine. "Honor, courage, commitment!" the aspiring fighters shout in unison.

The words come easy in this new class about ethics, but allegations that Marines killed women, children and unarmed captives in Iraq and Afghanistan suggest they might sometimes prove hard to live by.

"When you are out there, you are going to be challenged ... and it's not just in Iraq or Afghanistan," said Lt. Col. Robert Scott, commander of a recruit battalion at Marine Corps Recruit Depot in San Diego. "When you are on the horns of a moral dilemma, you need to refer back and think 'What would my senior [drill instructor] do?'"

To give recruits answers to that question, the Marine Corps is boosting training in values and battlefield ethics, requiring more hours of lessons on the issues than any other branch of the military does.

The Marine Corps commandant, Gen. James T. Conway, ordered the initiative in November, and a more rigorous diet of ethics training was introduced in May at the San Diego recruiting depot - one of the service's two training centers for enlistees, graduating about 20,000 Marines a year.

Conway routinely tours Marine bases and shares with the troops his concerns about the pending criminal cases, said a spokesman, Lt. Col. T.V. Johnson.

The most notorious active case is the 2005 killings of 24 Iraqi civilians at Haditha. A Marine squad used grenades and gunfire on the Iraqis after a roadside bomb killed a Marine. Women and children were among the dead.

Three enlisted Marines are charged with murder and four officers are accused of failing to investigate the deaths. The defendants say they killed the Iraqis because they believed they were under attack.

A Pentagon survey of 447 Marines in Iraq last year found fewer than half said they would report a member of their unit for killing or wounding an innocent civilian. Only 38 percent said noncombatants should be treated with dignity and respect.

During 12 weeks of boot camp, Marine trainees get 38 hours of values training, up from 24. The Army provides about 24 hours of instruction on core values and ethics, the Air Force 7 1/2 hours and the Navy about five hours.

The lessons start off simply: don't drink and drive, never sleep on guard duty, don't fraternize with officers. Then tougher issues are introduced, including what it means to kill someone.

Forty miles up the road at Camp Pendleton, hearing officers have been reviewing evidence against the Marines charged in the Haditha case. They recommended this past week that charges against one enlisted Marine be dropped but that the highest-ranking officer should face court-martial.

Special forces Marines also are being investigated for the shooting deaths of several civilians in Afghanistan, and a separate investigation is under way to see if Marines killed unarmed insurgent captives during a firefight in Fallujah in 2004. No one has been charged in those two cases.

David Brahms, a retired brigadier general who was formerly the top lawyer in the Marine Corps and now is a civilian lawyer, said criticism of troop behavior is unfair.

"You can't rule out women and children as noncombatants, everybody becomes the enemy," said Brahms, who has a client in the case of an Iraqi civilian killed at the town of Hamdania. "Sometimes you act in ways that upon reflection turn out to be inappropriate and inadvisable."

But for a Marine spokeswoman, Maj. Kristen Lasica, there are no gray areas.

"Honor, courage, commitment. You can't separate them from anything else," Lasica said. "If you get it, you are going to make the right decision no matter how hard it is."

Ellie