PDA

View Full Version : Hearing begins for two accused of sabotaging parachutes


thedrifter
03-19-03, 06:47 AM
March 18, 2003

Hearing begins for two accused of sabotaging parachutes

By Gary D. Robertson
Associated Press


CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. — Military prosecutors began Tuesday presenting their case against two Marines accused of attempted murder in the sabotage of parachutes, some of which failed during jump training.
Most of the morning session of the Article 32 hearing consisted of prosecutors turning over exhibits they want to use in a court-martial to Maj. Paul McConnell, who is serving as the civilian equivalent of a judge in the military court. McConnell was to examine the exhibits and determine which ones he will use in deciding if the Marines should be court-martialed.

Lance Cpl. Julian Ramirez of Los Angeles and Lance Cpl. Antoine D. Boykins of Baltimore were charged last month with attempted premeditated murder, reckless endangerment, conspiracy to commit premeditated murder and destruction of government property.

Three Marines suffered minor injuries Sept. 21 when their main parachutes failed, forcing them to use reserve chutes as they jumped from a C-17 Globemaster during heavy equipment parachute training.

Jumpmasters canceled the training and, on their return to Cherry Point Air Station, discovered suspension lines on 13 of 25 parachutes had been cut and repacked in such a way to avoid detection.

Before the hearing began, the civilian attorney for Ramirez said his client was disturbed by the charges.

“But at the same time, he feels he will be vindicated,” said Dick McNeil of Jacksonville.

The exhibits presented by prosecutors included statements from two of the men whose parachutes malfunctioned. The third man was testify at the hearing Tuesday afternoon. The exhibits also included statements from other members of the parachute team who did not jump.

The judge also will review a report by military investigators that focuses on DNA evidence found on one of the parachutes.

McNeil said Ramirez was a parachute rigger. The Marines said both men were air delivery specialists with 2nd Transportation Support Battalion, 2nd Force Support Group.

If convicted of all the charges, Ramirez could receive life in prison without parole, McNeil said.

“From the beginning of this, we’ve maintained his innocence,” McNeil said.

The two Marines have been held in the brig at Camp Lejeune since the end of January. Ramirez also was charged with unauthorized absence.

The afternoon before the incident, 20 jumpers when through training and their parachutes were stored in a large locker. There are only three keys to the parachute locker, officials said.

The parachutes were distributed at random, officials said, but it was unclear if they were assigned the night before. Each Marine carried his own parachute the day of the exercise.

An Article 32 hearing is the military equivalent of a grand jury hearing, although it is open and defense attorneys can cross-examine witnesses.




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright 2003 The Associated Press.

Sempers,

Roger

SheWolf
03-19-03, 09:41 AM
If they are found guilty,, cut the lines, put em up, and make em jump,,,,,

thedrifter
03-19-03, 12:10 PM
Article ran : 03/19/2003
Suspect's DNA found on chute
By Eric Steinkopff
DAILY NEWS STAFF

The DNA of one of two Marines accused of tampering with military parachutes before a September training exercise was found on sabotaged chutes, prosecutors said at a Tuesday hearing where one jumper described his brief, terrifying free fall.



“I was falling flat on my back with my chest facing the sun and streamers around my head,” said Chief Warrant Officer 3 Earl T. Hutchins, an engineer with Marine Wing Support Squadron 274, 2nd Marine Aircraft Wing.



Eventually, his reserve chute opened during the Sept. 21 jump.



“It was the worst landing I’ve ever had in all my jumps. I hit hard, and the air went out of my lungs. The next point I remember was waking up on the ground in pain,” said the veteran parachutist with nearly 70 jumps.



Suspension lines on 13 parachutes were cut prior to the exercise over Camp Davis. Three Marines were injured when they were forced to rely on reserve parachutes to save themselves from falling more than 1,200 feet.



Lance Cpl. Antoine D. Boykins, 21, of Baltimore, Md., and Lance Cpl. Julian C. Ramirez, 25, of Los Angeles, Calif., each face 13 counts of attempted premeditated murder along with charges of reckless endangerment, conspiracy to commit premeditated murder and destruction of government property.



Ramirez was also charged with unauthorized absence.



The maximum penalty if the accused are found guilty of all charges is life in prison without parole.



Investigators in October claimed that lines were cut and parachutes repacked in such a way that traditional inspection methods would not have detected the damage.



Boykins and Ramirez are air delivery specialists with Air Delivery Platoon, Beach and Terminal Operations Company, 2nd Transportation Battalion. Air delivery specialists, also known as riggers, have extensive training in packing parachutes.



The Article 32 hearing Tuesday at Camp Lejeune is the military equivalent of a grand jury to determine if there is sufficient evidence for a general court-martial.



Prosecuting attorneys introduced 35 exhibits into evidence, including Boykins’ DNA allegedly found on tampered parachutes seized by the Naval Criminal Investigation Service.



Also introduced were lab test results for latent fingerprints, a copy of a note found on the paraloft floor on McHugh Boulevard allegedly containing a list of sabotaged parachute serial numbers and four sworn statements from Boykins.



Stephen Greene, a technical specialist with the U.S. Army Criminal Investigative Lab in Forest Park, Ga., testified by telephone that Boykins’ fingerprints were discovered on some of the objects he was asked examine. He acknowledged that none of Ramirez’s fingerprints were found.



The prosecution did not introduce statements from Ramirez, but included military service record punishment pages on both of the accused suggesting retaliation as a possible motive for the crimes.



During the long walk from the defense wing of the Legal Support Services Section to the courtroom, the accused were accompanied by their attorneys and two military guards each.



The short, stocky Ramirez was quiet and seemed confident both in the courtroom and outside, while the tall, lanky Boykins seemed nervous.



“My client is upbeat because eventually he will be vindicated,” said one of Ramirez’s attorneys, Richard McNeil of Jacksonville.



One of Boykins’ attorneys, Bernard Alston from Henderson, objected to Hutchins’ entire testimony without success.



Military officials initially announced that the jumpers sustained only minor injuries, but Hutchins later went to the hospital for pain and recently discovered a torn rotator cuff and a rip between the muscle that connects his bicep to his shoulder.



“It was hideous the way the muscle was torn up in there,” Hutchins said of the exploratory operation video. “(The doctor) said that there was nothing he could do for me, and I’m trying to get into Chapel Hill or Portsmouth (Naval Regional Medical Center in Virginia) right now.”



The hearing is scheduled to continue today.







Contact Eric Steinkopff at esteinkopff@jdnews.com or at 353-1171, Ext. 236.




http://www.jacksonvilledailynews.com/photo/031903_marine.jpg

John Althouse/Daily News
Heading to hearing: Cpl. Julian C. Ramirez, front, and Lance Cpl. Antoine D. Boykins are escorted to their hearing at Camp Lejeune on Tuesday.


Sempers,

Roger