PDA

View Full Version : Vieques Island: No bombs, no base, no bucks



wrbones
02-03-03, 02:56 PM
Esta página no está disponible en español.

THE ORLANDO SENTINEL
Puerto Rico's Protests Cost It Navy's Bounty
No Bombs, No Base, No Bucks
Mike Thomas
January 14, 2003
Copyright © 2003 THE ORLANDO SENTINEL. All rights reserved.

It was great political grandstanding for politicians and activists to pummel the Navy over the Vieques island bombing range in Puerto Rico.

But it seems there was a glitch in their strategy.

They were so successful that the Navy not only is stopping the bombing, but also may abandon the neighboring Roosevelt Roads Naval Station on the main island.

It seems if you don't have a place to bomb, then you don't need a place to prepare to bomb.

Despite the simple logic of this, despite warnings by the Navy that it could happen, the news seems to be a shock to Puerto Rican leaders on and off the island.

Hey, we wanted the bombs to stop falling from the sky -- not the money!

Don't worry. If the Navy sails away with the $250 million it pumps into the local economy, there are options.

The first is ... Baldwin Shores!

Puerto Rico can bring in Orlando Mayor Glenda Hood, an expert in Navy base redevelopment. She could bring in the Pritzker family, which could buy the base for $24 worth of trinkets.

Then the Pritzkers could build zero-lot line homes on the ocean that 99 percent of the people there couldn't afford. Those sections of Vieques that hold unexploded ordnance could be sold to a Community Development District for public parks.

And let's not forget tourism.

Disney could use the west end of Vieques for cruise-ship stopovers. Then at night it would allow the Navy to bomb the east end as part of the laser-light show.

Puerto Rico better consider all possibilities because the Navy's position seems to be:

No bombs, no base, no bucks.

Adm. Robert Nater basically has given the next base-closure committee, which meets in 2005, clearance to put Roosevelt Roads on the list.

For those of us who have followed the Vieques story, the fallout from Nater's comments is puzzling.

For four years, we heard how the Navy has been a relentless bully. It has beaten protesters and even poisoned children. Eighty-one percent of Vieques residents voted the Navy off the island. Even the governor of Puerto Rico wanted the Navy out.

I supported their right to protest and even boot the Navy. But now we are hearing how beloved the Navy is and how politicians are demanding it stay. It's a bit late now.

For all the islanders who may lose their jobs, blame the activists and politicians who did not consider the full consequences of their actions.

If you want to keep your military base in these times of base closures, you don't eliminate its main reason for existing. If you want the butter, you have to put up with the guns.

Gov. Jeb Bush realizes that.

He actively courted the Navy to come bomb us after leaving Vieques. He knows the closure commission will come snooping around again in two years, and he wants our bases to be bustling and irreplaceable.

His office estimates that increased training could bring $800 million into the Florida economy -- some of that out of Puerto Rico's hide.

The Navy should clean up Vieques and give it back to Puerto Rico for economic development. The same should be done with Roosevelt Roads if that station no longer is needed.

It seems that the Navy may be getting ready to move on. Maybe it's time that Puerto Rico do likewise.

wrbones
02-03-03, 03:00 PM
www.puertorico-herald.org




DEFENSE DAILY
The Latest Word on Trends and Developments in Defense and Aerospace
Vieques Stakes Raised: Senate Bill Closes Roosevelt Roads Naval Base if Bombing Range Is Not Reopened
No Train, No Gain
September 27, 1999
Copyright © 1999 PHILLIPS BUSINESS INFORMATION, INC. All Rights Reserved.

In an attempt to raise the stakes in the political controversy surrounding the naval live-fire training range on the island of Vieques, Puerto Rico, Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) last week introduced a bill (S. 1602) that would require the United States to close the Navy base at Roosevelt Roads, Puerto Rico, if the Vieques training range is not reopened. Puerto Rican politicians and activists alike are advocating the permanent cessation of training on Vieques and the transfer of Navy property there to the people of Vieques.

"Maintaining Naval Station Roosevelt Roads without access to training ranges, including those on the island of Vieques, would not be the most efficient use of scarce readiness resources," the bill says.

Below is the text of S. 1602:


106TH CONGRESS
1ST SESSION
S. 1602



To require the closure of Naval Station Roosevelt Roads, Puerto Rico upon termination of Armed Forces use of training ranges on the island of Vieques, Puerto Rico, involving live munitions impact.
-----------------------------

IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
SEPTEMBER 21, 1999

Mr. Inhofe introduced the following bill, which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Armed Services

---------------------------------------------

A BILL

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

SECTION 1. CLOSURE OF NAVAL STATION ROOSEVELT ROADS, PUERTO RICO.


(a) FINDINGS- Congress makes the following findings:

The principal mission of Naval Station Roosevelt Roads, Puerto Rico, is to support the Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility.

The key component of the Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility is the set of training ranges on the island of Vieques, including the live impact area on the eastern tip of the island.

The other missions of Naval Station Roosevelt Roads, such as the performance of counter-drug operations by P-3 aircraft and the missions of the Special Operations Command, South, can be performed at other military facilities outside of Puerto Rico.

Military training operations, including the expenditure of live munitions, take place at a number of facilities in the continental United States and in Allied nations.

If access to training ranges such as those on the island of Vieques are terminated, the value of the Puerto Rican Operating Area and the requirements for maintaining Naval Station Roosevelt Roads are greatly diminished.

The Department of Defense must leverage its resources in the most cost-effective manner to ensure that it maximizes its ability to train its military forces.

Maintaining Naval Station Roosevelt Roads without access to training ranges, including those on the island of Vieques, would not be the most efficient use of scarce readiness resources.

(b) CONTINGENT REQUIREMENT FOR CLOSURE- Upon any termination of use of the training ranges on the island of Vieques for live munitions impact involved in the training of the Armed Forces, the Secretary of Defense shall transfer the missions, personnel, and assets of Naval Station Roosevelt Roads, Puerto Rico, to the continental United States and close Naval Station Roosevelt Roads. The Secretary may, however, transfer any counter-drug mission, together with associated personnel and assets, to a forward operation location outside the continental United States that is also outside the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

vance
02-03-03, 05:17 PM
Very interesting Bones! I have been at both installations . I believe the Navy is ready to cut their losses.