thedrifter
07-30-06, 10:02 AM
Tours extended for 4,000 GIs, raising doubt on pullout
By Edward Wong The New York Times
Published: July 30, 2006
BAGHDAD The tours of 4,000 U.S. soldiers who had been scheduled to leave Iraq in the coming weeks have been extended for up to four months, signaling that there would almost certainly be no significant troop withdrawal before the end of the year, military officials and analysts said.
The extension is part of the new security plan that President George W. Bush and Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki of Iraq announced last week in Washington.
The plan entails sending thousands of U.S. and Iraqi troops to the capital from elsewhere in Iraq to bolster the forces in the capital. Since the new Iraqi government was installed in May, sectarian violence has spiraled out of control in many parts of Baghdad.
Of the 4,000 troops ordered to stay beyond their standard one-year tour, 3,500 are from the 172nd Stryker Brigade Combat Team, currently based in the northern city of Mosul, said Lieutenant Colonel Barry Johnson, a military spokesman.
A separate military statement Saturday used slightly different numbers: The release said that 3,700 members of the 172nd Brigade were being sent to Baghdad.
The eight-wheel Stryker vehicles are smaller and more maneuverable than the Bradley fighting vehicles and M1 Abrams tanks, making them better suited for urban combat.
The new security plan allows almost no room for significant troop withdrawals by the end of 2006, Anthony Cordesman, a military analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, said in an interview Saturday.
If any troop withdrawal takes place in the coming months, "it would be so cosmetic that it would be meaningless," he said. "It would be statistical gamesmanship.
"People are now talking about 2009 as the goal for achieving really serious security," he added.
The issue of when troops should be withdrawn has stirred political debate and pressure, especially with midterm elections coming up in November. Several leading Democrats in Congress have pressed for a deadline of the end of the year for withdrawing most troops, and some Republicans are also calling for a significant withdrawal by then.
The top U.S. commander in Iraq, General George Casey Jr., recently drafted a plan that projected sharp reductions in troop numbers by the end of 2007, with the first cuts coming this September.
Under this plan, two combat brigades scheduled to rotate out in September - about 3,500 soldiers per brigade - would not be replaced. But given the new focus on Baghdad, such a move would be almost impossible.
As of Saturday, there were 127,000 U.S. troops in the country, Johnson said. Numbers fluctuate when units overlap while deploying in and out of Iraq. So the total troop level will rise above 130,000 as new units rotate in and the 4,000 troops are held longer.
The 172nd Stryker Brigade was deployed to Mosul in August 2005. The brigade had been preparing to return to its home base, Fort Wainwright, Alaska, when the Pentagon ordered a tour extension.
Many military officials have said that asking soldiers to serve more than a year at a time in Iraq grinds away at morale and motivation. That is one of the reasons that marines usually do six- or seven-month tours here rather than a full year, which the army prefers.
In the spring of 2004, morale plummeted among soldiers of the 1st Armored Division when they were asked to stay beyond their yearlong tour in order to quell a Shiite uprising.
At the time, the 1st Armored Division had already spent a year trying to gain control of Baghdad, one of the most dangerous assignments in the country. Units were then sent to the Shiite holy cities of Najaf and Karbala to engage in fierce battles with the Mahdi Army, the militia founded by Moktada al-Sadr, the anti-American cleric.
The new Baghdad security plan calls for adding at least 4,000 U.S. troops and 4,000 Iraqi security troops in the capital. There are currently 9,000 U.S. troops, 8,500 Iraqi soldiers and 34,500 Iraqi police officers in Baghdad.
The military said Saturday in a written statement that "the duration of the temporary deployment of these Iraqi and coalition forces in Baghdad will be determined by conditions on the ground."
Abdul Razzaq al-Saiedi contributed reporting for this article.
Ellie
By Edward Wong The New York Times
Published: July 30, 2006
BAGHDAD The tours of 4,000 U.S. soldiers who had been scheduled to leave Iraq in the coming weeks have been extended for up to four months, signaling that there would almost certainly be no significant troop withdrawal before the end of the year, military officials and analysts said.
The extension is part of the new security plan that President George W. Bush and Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki of Iraq announced last week in Washington.
The plan entails sending thousands of U.S. and Iraqi troops to the capital from elsewhere in Iraq to bolster the forces in the capital. Since the new Iraqi government was installed in May, sectarian violence has spiraled out of control in many parts of Baghdad.
Of the 4,000 troops ordered to stay beyond their standard one-year tour, 3,500 are from the 172nd Stryker Brigade Combat Team, currently based in the northern city of Mosul, said Lieutenant Colonel Barry Johnson, a military spokesman.
A separate military statement Saturday used slightly different numbers: The release said that 3,700 members of the 172nd Brigade were being sent to Baghdad.
The eight-wheel Stryker vehicles are smaller and more maneuverable than the Bradley fighting vehicles and M1 Abrams tanks, making them better suited for urban combat.
The new security plan allows almost no room for significant troop withdrawals by the end of 2006, Anthony Cordesman, a military analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, said in an interview Saturday.
If any troop withdrawal takes place in the coming months, "it would be so cosmetic that it would be meaningless," he said. "It would be statistical gamesmanship.
"People are now talking about 2009 as the goal for achieving really serious security," he added.
The issue of when troops should be withdrawn has stirred political debate and pressure, especially with midterm elections coming up in November. Several leading Democrats in Congress have pressed for a deadline of the end of the year for withdrawing most troops, and some Republicans are also calling for a significant withdrawal by then.
The top U.S. commander in Iraq, General George Casey Jr., recently drafted a plan that projected sharp reductions in troop numbers by the end of 2007, with the first cuts coming this September.
Under this plan, two combat brigades scheduled to rotate out in September - about 3,500 soldiers per brigade - would not be replaced. But given the new focus on Baghdad, such a move would be almost impossible.
As of Saturday, there were 127,000 U.S. troops in the country, Johnson said. Numbers fluctuate when units overlap while deploying in and out of Iraq. So the total troop level will rise above 130,000 as new units rotate in and the 4,000 troops are held longer.
The 172nd Stryker Brigade was deployed to Mosul in August 2005. The brigade had been preparing to return to its home base, Fort Wainwright, Alaska, when the Pentagon ordered a tour extension.
Many military officials have said that asking soldiers to serve more than a year at a time in Iraq grinds away at morale and motivation. That is one of the reasons that marines usually do six- or seven-month tours here rather than a full year, which the army prefers.
In the spring of 2004, morale plummeted among soldiers of the 1st Armored Division when they were asked to stay beyond their yearlong tour in order to quell a Shiite uprising.
At the time, the 1st Armored Division had already spent a year trying to gain control of Baghdad, one of the most dangerous assignments in the country. Units were then sent to the Shiite holy cities of Najaf and Karbala to engage in fierce battles with the Mahdi Army, the militia founded by Moktada al-Sadr, the anti-American cleric.
The new Baghdad security plan calls for adding at least 4,000 U.S. troops and 4,000 Iraqi security troops in the capital. There are currently 9,000 U.S. troops, 8,500 Iraqi soldiers and 34,500 Iraqi police officers in Baghdad.
The military said Saturday in a written statement that "the duration of the temporary deployment of these Iraqi and coalition forces in Baghdad will be determined by conditions on the ground."
Abdul Razzaq al-Saiedi contributed reporting for this article.
Ellie