View Full Version : One Marine Remembers His Beirut Brothers 20 Years Later
10-17-03, 09:33 AM
This was sent to me by Phantom Blooper..... <br />
The BLT is gone!" <br />
The staff sergeant bellowed his message to the major as the officer watched a billowing mushroom cloud rise hundreds of feet in...
10-17-03, 09:36 AM
As the mission statement made its way along the chain of command, the original statement was modified formally on four occasions, although the original version remained largely intact. However, the intent was ambiguous, and in hindsight, this appeared to be a key contributor to the BLT bombing.
The original mission statement provided by the Joint Chiefs of Staff read: "To establish an environment which will permit the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF) to carry out their responsibilities in the Beirut area. When directed, USCINCEUR will introduce U.S. forces as part of a multinational force presence in the Beirut area to occupy and secure positions along a designated section of the line from south of the Beirut International Airport to a position in the vicinity of the Presidential palace; be prepared to protect U.S. forces; and, on order, conduct retrograde operations as required."
A special commission was appointed by the Secretary of Defense in November 1983 to conduct an independent inquiry into the 23 Oct. terrorist bombing. Named the Long Commission after its chairman, retired Admiral Robert L. J. Long, the commission of five flag-level officers concluded that the mission statement and concept of operations were passed down the chain of command with little amplification.
As a result, the commission concluded that "perceptual differences as to the precise meaning and importance of the 'presence' role of the USMNF [United States Multinational Force] existed throughout the chain of command. Similarly, the exact responsibilities of the USMNF commander regarding the security of Beirut International Airport were not clearly delineated in his mission tasking."
The inquiry clearly established that the MAU commanders on the ground in Beirut interpreted their "presence" mission to require the USMNF to be visible, but not to appear to be threatening to the populace.
"This concern was a factor in most decisions made by the MAU commanders in the employment and disposition of their forces," the report concluded. "The MAU commander regularly assessed the effect of contemplated security actions on the 'presence' mission."
"The mission from the start was opaque, nebulous," said now retired Col Timothy J. "Tim" Geraghty, who was CO of the 24th MAU during the time of the bombing.
"It was intentionally written that way, in generic terms," he said. "It was a complex mission, and the presence concept was relatively untested. It required a special kind of discipline on the part of the troops exercising it." He believes that is why Marines were sent in.
"But when you look at this sort of mission in terms of what we all learn as Marines, it flies in the face of all our doctrine. The decision to send us in was made with good intentions, but it was made from the heart rather than from the facts," he concluded.
From the beginning, Marines were supposed to be a neutral force, there to provide a buffer between warring sides. And there were many sides. At that time, Lebanon contained 17 officially recognized religious sects, two foreign armies of occupation, four national contingents of a multinational force (Britain joined the MNF later), seven national contributors to a U.N. peacekeeping force and some two dozen extralegal militias.
"Marines are an assault force, trained to bring the fight to the enemy," said Geraghty. "We hadn't heard of this sort of mission. The mission was palatable at the time the decision was made for us to go in, but the situation changed, and the mission wasn't allowed to change with it."
One of the first duties Marines undertook was to conduct individual and small-unit training for the LAF. That, plus the fact that Marines began manning joint outposts with the LAF, gave the impression that the United States was favoring the established Lebanese government. This did not set well with many of the warring parties, including Israel.
In January 1983, the Israelis began testing American lines, and there were at least five attempts that month to penetrate Marine positions. One noted incident involved Marine Captain Charles "Chuck" Johnson.
On 2 Feb., the captain observed three Israeli Centurion tanks moving on the LAF checkpoint outside the Lebanese University. In his view, the tanks were moving at battle speed. Johnson interjected himself bodily between the tanks and the checkpoint, stopped them and informed the Israeli tank commander that they would cross that checkpoint "over my dead body." When two of the tanks attempted to ram past him, he jumped on the commander's tank with a locked and cocked .45 and demanded that the commander order the tanks to stop and turn around. They did.
The 24th MAU, with BLT 1/8 as the landing force, relieved the 22d on 30 May 1983. For the MAU and many of the Marines in it, this would be the second tour in Beirut, but the situation had changed considerably since their first time.
Minor incidents had been occurring early in 1983, and on 16 March several Marines received minor injuries from a grenade attack on their routine patrol. But on 18 April, the American Embassy in Beirut was bombed, killing 17 U.S. citizens, including a Marine security guard, and about 40 others. The 2,000 pounds of explosives were delivered by a pickup truck.
In June, Marines began conducting combined patrols with the LAF. The patrols proved to be nerve-wracking, as local youngsters tested Marines by hurling objects at them or pointing at them with the barrels of toy weapons, which looked very real.
In July, Lebanese President Amin Gemayel traveled to Washington and obtained a promise for expedited delivery of military equipment for the LAF. On 22 July, militia mortar and artillery shelled the Beirut International Airport (BIA), wounding three Marines and closing the airport temporarily.
On 28 Aug., a Sunday, the situation took a drastic turn as the Israeli military initiated a withdrawal from the Beirut area, and the LAF scampered to take up their positions before one of the competing factions did. This jockeying for position put Marines in the crossfire of many factional firefights. "Stray rounds" impacting in Marine positions became a regular occurrence.
Marines returned fire for the first time on 28 Aug. after intense interfactional fighting became direct fire on Marines, beginning a spiraling departure from neutrality. On the 29th, Marines took their first casualties as a result of direct fire when "Alpha" Company's Second Lieutenant George Losey and SSgt Alexander Ortega were killed by a direct hit from an 82 mm mortar.
"The lieutenant and staff sergeant had gone into the command post tent to get radio batteries because we'd lost comm on a couple of radios," Sergeant Donald Williams told reporters afterward. "They were only in there for 30 seconds," said the Alpha Co squad leader who witnessed the event. The direct mortar hit also injured five noncommissioned officers who were checking the lines.
Capt Paul Roy, Alpha Co commanding officer, told reporters later that day, "The LAF was moving through the area and stopped to reconsolidate in our position, bringing intense artillery and mortar fire down on us.
"Our Marines had to make very sure that the fire was directed at them, and that their lives were in danger," said Roy. "They followed the rules of engagement and got permission before they fired back."
This sort of restraint and discipline under fire is what Col Geraghty hopes is never forgotten.
"I was then, and still am, extremely proud of the Marines in Beirut," he said. "They carried out a very tough mission, under extremely trying circumstances, and their discipline under fire was magnificent. I would put their performance up against any other fighting force in history."
Through September the fighting remained intense. Marines who were decorated Vietnam veterans declared that they had never been through such intense mortar, artillery and rocket barrages. Marines were forced more and more into escalating weapons duels. In late September, a light antitank assault weapon (LAAW) was used to take out a sniper bunker-the first time a LAAW had been fired in combat since Vietnam, according to Eric Hammel in "The Root."
Naval gunfire was employed, to the point where on 25 Sept., the battleship USS New Jersey (BB-62) with her mammoth 16-inch guns was brought to bear on Syrian artillery batteries pounding Marine positions.
Not coincidentally, on 26 Sept. a cease-fire was negotiated between Saudi and Syrian mediators. It was the first and wouldn't be the last, but none of them lasted more than the time it took for one of the factions to become impatient and start the fray again. These serious games of cat and mouse continued into October.
Then, on the still and quiet morning of Sunday, 23 Oct. 1983, a Marine sentry would try in vain to flip the magazine into his M16 and chamber a round to fire at the white Mercedes dump truck that was barreling down on his position. He would manage to get a couple rounds off, but too late. His post was just outside the "Beirut Hilton," the four-story building that housed more than 400 sleeping Marines.
10-17-03, 09:38 AM
Seconds later, 241 military personnel, mostly Marines, were dead, and more than a hundred others injured. It was a day that, for those who were there, would go down in infamy. Eighteen years later, as the Twin Towers in New York fell to terrorist plane bombs, Root vets could identify.
"Seeing the towers fall and the dust that enveloped the city did bring back memories for me, and I felt the adrenaline rush just like I felt on 23 October 1983," said William J. Sickles, a CH-46 helicopter crew chief who saw the aftermath as they were evacuating wounded.
"At first they told us the French contingent had been hit, but we noticed as we brought wounded on board that there were American flags on their sleeves," he recalled. The French were also hit with a terrorist truck bomb at the same time, killing 58 French paratroopers.
Michael L. Toma was a 20-year-old lance corporal asleep on the first floor, about 100 feet from where the truck exploded. He didn't know what hit him. "When I came to, I remember they were carrying me out on a stretcher head first, and I saw the sunlight and blue sky. I should not have been able to see the sky so quickly. The building was gone." The scenes of the 9-11 rescues were reminiscent of those on 10-23-83 to Toma, who survived with relatively minor injuries.
"Even before the first tower fell, my throat was closing up. I could smell the cement dust, the residue from explosives, the smell of bodies," reflected Reggie Fields, who was a Navy chief journalist assigned to the mobile broadcasting service ashore in Beirut. "It was just like being there on that Sunday morning in Beirut."
"Beirut was the first major attack in what has now become World War III," observed Bob Jordan, who, in 1992, founded the Beirut Veterans of America, whose motto is, "Our first duty is to remember." The organization will conduct a 20th year remembrance at Camp Lejeune, 21-23 Oct.
After the bombing, the mission in Beirut took on a whole new level of gravity for the remainder of the 24th MAU's time there and for the members of the 22d MAU and BLT 2/8 who came in as replacements.
Between the bombing and the time Marines would be totally pulled out of Beirut in February 1984 (except for 100 at the embassy who left in August 1984), more Marines were killed or wounded. Stories of bravery and combat valor rivaled those of any other in Marine history from the halls of Montezuma to the shores of Tripoli.
Take Sgt Manuel A. "Manny" Cox, for example. He was a squad leader in Golf Co, 2/8. His squad manned Observation Post 76 on 4 Dec. 1983. That was the same day the United States lost two fighter-bombers in air strikes against Syrian targets, with one pilot killed and the other captured.
Cox's squad came under fire by Shiites bent on killing them all and stealing their weapons and ammunition. By all accounts the fighting was ferocious. It lasted for hours, and Sgt Cox conducted himself in a manner that was described by one observer as "simply awesome."
"He called for and adjusted artillery fire and mortars, gave fire commands to his Marines, the whole deal. He and his Marines fought like hell that night," said Mike Ettore, a fellow Marine who said he was monitoring the fight on radio. "Somebody got an hour of the fight on a tape recording. I've always thought they should have that tape in squad leader school and say, 'OK, listen to this. Here's how Marines should be led in combat.' "
Tragically, the last enemy round of the night made a direct hit on OP 76, killing Cox and seven of his Marines.
Then there was Lance Corporal Harold Clayburn, who crawled 300 meters on his belly, as the Shiites tried to shoot him, to get to Cox's position to assess the situation. The scene at OP 76 was utter carnage. When he crawled back to inform his CO, he had to return, this time with the CO, to bring back the crypto gear he'd forgotten to retrieve.
Even after the MNF left in August, there were deaths, such as Army Warrant Officer Ken Welch and Navy Chief Petty Officer Ray Wagner—killed by a terrorist car bomb at the East Embassy Annex in September 1984. The sacrifices continued until the day everyone left.
Looking back, one has to ask, "Was it worth it?"
"We were making a difference; that's why they had to attack us," said Geraghty. "We were providing the stability that was allowing the various factions in the military and the government to begin to pull together."
How does that translate into today's terms?
Geraghty said, "9-11 woke the sleeping giant. Things will never be the same again."
Editor's note: Retired CWO-4 Gaddo, as a staff sergeant, served in Beirut, Lebanon, with the 24th MAU in 1983. He had established a photo lab on the third deck of the Marine barracks that was destroyed by the terrorist truck bomb. He retired from the Marine Corps in 1996 and is director of Parks, Recreation and Library Services for Peachtree City, Ga.
"The First Duty is to Remember"
Lord, where do we get such men?"
General Paul X. Kelley, 28th Commandant of the Marine Corps, wondered aloud after presenting LCpl Jeffrey Lee Nashton, a survivor, with a special gift at Maryland's Bethesda Naval Hospital, 15 Nov. 1983, while Nashton's wife, Laurie, looked on.
Gen Kelley previously had visited with LCpl Nashton in the intensive care ward at Frankfurt, Germany, 25 Oct. The general said he observed Nashton "with more tubes going in and out of his body than I have ever seen. When he heard me say who I was, he grabbed my coat, went up to the collar and counted the stars. He squeezed my hand, and then he wrote, 'Semper Fi.' " In Bethesda, Gen Kelley presented Nashton with his four stars, the Marine Corps emblem and the words "Semper Fi" inscribed on a plaque.
Gen Kelley later said, "When I left the hospital, I realized I had met a great human being, and I took off those stars because at the time I felt they belonged more to him than to me." (Photo by SSgt E. R. Giddens)
10-27-03, 03:59 PM
My only question is...........When do we return to finish the job
So it doesnt look like our brothers died for nothing.
I only recently found out about this site. I wanted to thank you on a personal note. Specifically, I have been trying for years to find any articles concerning SSGT Alexander Ortega who was killed in Beirut on August 29, 1983. I know there was a book about what was going on in Beirut at that time and it listed all of the names of the service men that were killed defending freedom. Unfortunatley I do not know the title of the book.
SSGT Ortega was one of 2 recruiters that I had back in 1982 when I enlisted in high school. We developed a bond between the 3 of us that forever will be imbedded in my mind and heart.
I was in Boot Camp in Parris Island when I heard on the news that Alex was killed. Being a new recruit I immediately wanted to go to Beirut and kill anybody from that area of the world for retaliation of the killing of my friend.
For my safety, my other recruiter made some phone calls to make sure I stayed state side so I did not put my own life as well as other Marines in danger due to my inexperience.
It has been almost 23 years and I have not forgotten Alex. I know his younger brother had enlisted shortly after his death. He left behind many people that loved him. He had a truely charismatic personality.
I made a photo album and saved all of the clippings that I could pertaining to SSGT. Ortega's death, and from time to time I look through it and remind myself that with all of the people in the world there are a handful that really make a difference in ones life, and Alex was one of those people.
If anyone knows the tiltle of the book that was written in approx. 1983 - 1984 listing the names of all of the service men killed in Beirut please post it.
Thank you again.
05-20-06, 11:03 AM
The name of the book is The Root, by Eric Hammel. A site you might want to check out is www.beirut-memorial.org